5 Misconceptions about Medieval Sieges in Movies

SandRhoman History May 29, 2022
Video Thumbnail
SandRhoman History Logo

SandRhoman History

@sandrhomanhistory

About

We want to entertain people with history which is entertaining, visually pleasing and grounded in scholarship at the same time. Our golden rules: 1) We only use academic sources and always try to stick to the consensus opinion. 2) We always list our sources in description of our videos. 3) We make clear when we deviate from the prior two rules. Education: Between the two of us we hold two Master's degrees in history from the university of Bern and one degree as a history teacher from the Bern University of Teacher Education. Both of us worked at the University of Bern as teaching assistants. We wrote an article about our experience as content creators (ed. by Dr. Kilian Baur and Robert Trautmannsberger): https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110792898-005/html We also held a few talks about our journey on YouTube at the universities of Eichstätt, Fribourg and Zürich. We taught a seminar about history on YouTube at the University of Zurich in spring of 2024.

Video Description

Get the exclusive NordVPN Deal here: https://nordvpn.com/sandrhoman It's risk free with Nord's 30-day-money-back-guarantee! Medieval sieges have become a favorite of moviemakers and game studios. Impenetrable walls, spectacular siege engines, a good dose of hands-on fighting and destruction make for an ideal canvas for heroism and drama. As history buffs we celebrate this attention. As historians, we often shed a tear. In general, most sieges were by far not as spectacular as depicted in popular media. Historical authenticity often falls victim to drama. Over time, the emphasis on dramatic storytelling in pop culture together with the doubtful work of some historians have created several misconceptions about medieval sieges. In this video we’re going to tackle five of these misunderstandings and look at one controversial aspect as a bonus at the end. Patreon (thank you): https://www.patreon.com/sandrhomanhistory Merch store: https://sandrhoman.creator-spring.com/ Paypal (thank you): https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/SandRhomanhistory Twitter: https://twitter.com/Sandrhoman Chapters: 00:00-00:51 Intro 00:51-03:27 Crumbling Walls? 03:27-05:35 Easy Breaches? 05:35-06:35 Nord VPN 06:35-09:13 Living the Good Life? 09:13-10:54 Tent Cities? 10:54-13:00 Siege Towers? 13:00-15:34 Throwing Things from the Walls? Bibliography: In this video we heavily relied on Rogers, C. J., Soldiers’ Lives Through History. The Middle Ages, Westport 2007. Further reading: Bradbury, J., The Medieval Siege, Woodbridge 1992. DeVries, K./ Smith, R. D., Medieval Military Technology, Toronto 2012. McGlynn, S., s. v. “Siege Warfare” in: Clifford J. Rogers (ed), The Oxford Encyclopedia of Medieval Warfare and Military Technology, 2010. Purton, P., A History of the Early Medieval Siege, C. 450-1220, Woodbridge 2009. Purton, P., A History of the Late Medieval Siege, 1200-1500, Woodbridge 2010.

You May Also Like

Upgrade Your Game

AI-recommended products based on this video

Loading...
95MM T129215SU Cooling Fan for ASUS ROG Strix for GeForce RTX 3060 3070 3080 3090 Ti Graphics Card CF1010U12S/D T129215BU(Black A-Fan T12)

95MM T129215SU Cooling Fan for ASUS ROG Strix for GeForce RTX 3060 3070 3080 3090 Ti Graphics Card CF1010U12S/D T129215BU(Black A-Fan T12)

(0)
$43.56
FREE delivery Mar 19 - Apr 10
Loading...
ASUS ROG Strix G16 Gaming Laptop, GeForce RTX 5070 Ti 12GB GDDR7, AMD Ryzen 9 8940HX, 64GB DDR5, 2TB SSD, Backlit Keyboard, Wi-Fi 6E, 16" WUXGA 165Hz Display, Win 11, Gray, 1TB Docking Station Set

ASUS ROG Strix G16 Gaming Laptop, GeForce RTX 5070 Ti 12GB GDDR7, AMD Ryzen 9 8940HX, 64GB DDR5, 2TB SSD, Backlit Keyboard, Wi-Fi 6E, 16" WUXGA 165Hz Display, Win 11, Gray, 1TB Docking Station Set

(10)
$4,269.00
FREE delivery Feb 24 - Mar 5
Loading...
ASUS ROG Strix G16 (2024) Gaming Laptop, 16” 16:10 FHD+ 165Hz, GeForce RTX 4060, Intel Core i7-13650HX, 16GB DDR5, 1TB PCIe SSD, Wi-Fi 6E, Windows 11, G614JV-AS71-CA

ASUS ROG Strix G16 (2024) Gaming Laptop, 16” 16:10 FHD+ 165Hz, GeForce RTX 4060, Intel Core i7-13650HX, 16GB DDR5, 1TB PCIe SSD, Wi-Fi 6E, Windows 11, G614JV-AS71-CA

(43)
$1,659.99$1,549.30
FREE delivery Feb 19 - 23
Loading...
Asus ROG Gladius III Wireless AimPoint Gaming Mouse, Connectivity (2.4GHz RF, Bluetooth, Wired), 36000 DPI Sensor, 6 programmable Buttons, ROG SpeedNova, Replaceable switches, Paracord Cable, White

Asus ROG Gladius III Wireless AimPoint Gaming Mouse, Connectivity (2.4GHz RF, Bluetooth, Wired), 36000 DPI Sensor, 6 programmable Buttons, ROG SpeedNova, Replaceable switches, Paracord Cable, White

(329)
$94.99$93.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jan 3
50+ bought in past month
Loading...
230W Charger Compatible with Razer Blade 14” 15” 16" 17” (2025-2018) RZ09 RTX-3060/3070/3080/4060/4070 Gaming Laptop RC30-0530 RC30-0238 RC30-0248 Replacement Power Adapter

230W Charger Compatible with Razer Blade 14” 15” 16" 17” (2025-2018) RZ09 RTX-3060/3070/3080/4060/4070 Gaming Laptop RC30-0530 RC30-0238 RC30-0248 Replacement Power Adapter

(16)
$67.99
FREE delivery Mon, Feb 16
Loading...
MSI Stealth A18 AI+ A3XWIG-013CA 18" UHD+ mini LED 120Hz Gaming Laptop, AMD Ryzen AI 9 HX 370, RTX 5080, 64GB DDR5, 2TB NVMe SSD, Windows 11 Home

MSI Stealth A18 AI+ A3XWIG-013CA 18" UHD+ mini LED 120Hz Gaming Laptop, AMD Ryzen AI 9 HX 370, RTX 5080, 64GB DDR5, 2TB NVMe SSD, Windows 11 Home

(1)
$4,499.00
FREE delivery Sat, Jan 3
Loading...
MSI Stealth 18 HX AI 18” 240Hz QHD+ Gaming Laptop: Intel Ultra 9-275HX, NVIDIA Geforce RTX 5080, 32GB DDR5, 2TB NVMe SSD, Wi-Fi 7, Win 11 Home :Midnight Black A2XWIG-045US

MSI Stealth 18 HX AI 18” 240Hz QHD+ Gaming Laptop: Intel Ultra 9-275HX, NVIDIA Geforce RTX 5080, 32GB DDR5, 2TB NVMe SSD, Wi-Fi 7, Win 11 Home :Midnight Black A2XWIG-045US

(12)
$3,999.00$3,587.85
FREE delivery Sat, Jan 3
Loading...
230W Charger Compatible with Razer Blade 14” 15” 16" 17” (2025-2018) RZ09 RTX-3060/3070/3080/4060/4070 Gaming Laptop RC30-0530 RC30-0238 RC30-0248 Replacement Power Adapter

230W Charger Compatible with Razer Blade 14” 15” 16" 17” (2025-2018) RZ09 RTX-3060/3070/3080/4060/4070 Gaming Laptop RC30-0530 RC30-0238 RC30-0248 Replacement Power Adapter

(16)
$67.99
FREE delivery Mon, Feb 16
Loading...
Lenovo LOQ 15.6" FHD 144Hz Gaming Laptop, Intel Core i5-12450HX, NVIDIA GeForce RTX 2050, 16GB DDR5, 2TB Storage (1TB SSD+1TB Docking Station Set), Number Pad, 720p Camera, Wi-Fi 6, Win 11, Gray

Lenovo LOQ 15.6" FHD 144Hz Gaming Laptop, Intel Core i5-12450HX, NVIDIA GeForce RTX 2050, 16GB DDR5, 2TB Storage (1TB SSD+1TB Docking Station Set), Number Pad, 720p Camera, Wi-Fi 6, Win 11, Gray

(2)
$1,369.00
FREE delivery Feb 24 - Mar 5
Loading...
Acer Nitro V 16 AI Gaming Laptop, 16" WUXGA 180Hz Display, AMD Ryzen 5 240, GeForce RTX 5050, 16GB DDR5, 512GB SSD, Backlit Keyboard, Copilot, Wi-Fi 6E, Win 11, Black, 1TB Docking Station Set

Acer Nitro V 16 AI Gaming Laptop, 16" WUXGA 180Hz Display, AMD Ryzen 5 240, GeForce RTX 5050, 16GB DDR5, 512GB SSD, Backlit Keyboard, Copilot, Wi-Fi 6E, Win 11, Black, 1TB Docking Station Set

(40)
$1,399.00
FREE delivery Feb 24 - Mar 5
Loading...
Lenovo Legion 5 15.1" WQXGA 165Hz Gaming Laptop, Intel i9 14900HX, GeForce RTX 5070 8GB GDDR7, 16GB DDR5, 2TB Storage(1TB SSD+1TB Docking Station Set), 24-Zone RGB Backlit Keyboard, Windows 11, Black

Lenovo Legion 5 15.1" WQXGA 165Hz Gaming Laptop, Intel i9 14900HX, GeForce RTX 5070 8GB GDDR7, 16GB DDR5, 2TB Storage(1TB SSD+1TB Docking Station Set), 24-Zone RGB Backlit Keyboard, Windows 11, Black

(68)
$2,749.00
FREE delivery Feb 24 - Mar 5
Loading...
UGREEN USB WiFi Adapter AX900 Entry-Level WiFi 6 Dongle Dual Band for PC Desktop with Antenna 5GHz 600Mbps, 2.4GHz 287Mbps Compatible with Windows 11 10

UGREEN USB WiFi Adapter AX900 Entry-Level WiFi 6 Dongle Dual Band for PC Desktop with Antenna 5GHz 600Mbps, 2.4GHz 287Mbps Compatible with Windows 11 10

(429)
$16.99
50+ bought in past month
Loading...
ARZOPA Portable Monitor, 16.1" FHD 1080P Kickstand 100% sRGB High Color Gamut Portable Laptop Monitor IPS Eye Care Screen for High-end Office & Entertainment - Z1C

ARZOPA Portable Monitor, 16.1" FHD 1080P Kickstand 100% sRGB High Color Gamut Portable Laptop Monitor IPS Eye Care Screen for High-end Office & Entertainment - Z1C

(2,728)
$129.99
FREE delivery Tue, Aug 12
100+ bought in past month
Loading...
llano RGB Laptop Cooling Pad with Powerful Turbofan Gaming Cooler Radiator with Infinitely Variable Speed, Touch Control, LCD Screen, 3-Port USB Hub, Seal Foam for Notebook Computer 15-19in

llano RGB Laptop Cooling Pad with Powerful Turbofan Gaming Cooler Radiator with Infinitely Variable Speed, Touch Control, LCD Screen, 3-Port USB Hub, Seal Foam for Notebook Computer 15-19in

(1,404)
$129.99
Prime
200+ bought in past month
Loading...
Logitech G203 Wired Gaming Mouse, 8,000 DPI, Rainbow Optical Effect LIGHTSYNC RGB, 6 Programmable Buttons, On-Board Memory, Screen Mapping, PC/Mac Computer and Laptop Compatible - Black
Best Seller

Logitech G203 Wired Gaming Mouse, 8,000 DPI, Rainbow Optical Effect LIGHTSYNC RGB, 6 Programmable Buttons, On-Board Memory, Screen Mapping, PC/Mac Computer and Laptop Compatible - Black

(17,871)
$27.98$22.38
FREE delivery Tue, Oct 14 on your first order
500+ bought in past month
Loading...
230W Charger Compatible with Razer Blade 14” 15” 16" 17” (2025-2018) RZ09 RTX-3060/3070/3080/4060/4070 Gaming Laptop RC30-0530 RC30-0238 RC30-0248 Replacement Power Adapter

230W Charger Compatible with Razer Blade 14” 15” 16" 17” (2025-2018) RZ09 RTX-3060/3070/3080/4060/4070 Gaming Laptop RC30-0530 RC30-0238 RC30-0248 Replacement Power Adapter

(16)
$67.99
FREE delivery Mon, Feb 16
Loading...
Lenovo LOQ 15.6" FHD 144Hz Gaming Laptop, Intel Core i5-12450HX, NVIDIA GeForce RTX 2050, 16GB DDR5, 2TB Storage (1TB SSD+1TB Docking Station Set), Number Pad, 720p Camera, Wi-Fi 6, Win 11, Gray

Lenovo LOQ 15.6" FHD 144Hz Gaming Laptop, Intel Core i5-12450HX, NVIDIA GeForce RTX 2050, 16GB DDR5, 2TB Storage (1TB SSD+1TB Docking Station Set), Number Pad, 720p Camera, Wi-Fi 6, Win 11, Gray

(2)
$1,369.00
FREE delivery Feb 24 - Mar 5
Loading...
Acer Nitro V 16 AI Gaming Laptop, 16" WUXGA 180Hz Display, AMD Ryzen 5 240, GeForce RTX 5050, 16GB DDR5, 512GB SSD, Backlit Keyboard, Copilot, Wi-Fi 6E, Win 11, Black, 1TB Docking Station Set

Acer Nitro V 16 AI Gaming Laptop, 16" WUXGA 180Hz Display, AMD Ryzen 5 240, GeForce RTX 5050, 16GB DDR5, 512GB SSD, Backlit Keyboard, Copilot, Wi-Fi 6E, Win 11, Black, 1TB Docking Station Set

(40)
$1,399.00
FREE delivery Feb 24 - Mar 5
Loading...
Lenovo Legion 5 15.1" WQXGA 165Hz Gaming Laptop, Intel i9 14900HX, GeForce RTX 5070 8GB GDDR7, 16GB DDR5, 2TB Storage(1TB SSD+1TB Docking Station Set), 24-Zone RGB Backlit Keyboard, Windows 11, Black

Lenovo Legion 5 15.1" WQXGA 165Hz Gaming Laptop, Intel i9 14900HX, GeForce RTX 5070 8GB GDDR7, 16GB DDR5, 2TB Storage(1TB SSD+1TB Docking Station Set), 24-Zone RGB Backlit Keyboard, Windows 11, Black

(68)
$2,749.00
FREE delivery Feb 24 - Mar 5