Dark Souls 2 critiques are SLOP.

The Firelink Conspiracy October 3, 2025
Video Thumbnail
The Firelink Conspiracy Logo

The Firelink Conspiracy

@thefirelinkconspiracy

About

I analyze From Software games as masterpieces of literature with cohesive, overarching narratives, plots with build-ups and pay-offs, themes and ideas. May you be welcome here!

Video Description

In this video, I'll debunk the Dark Souls 2 critique that started it all - Matthewmatosis' video. I'll be addressing other critiques/reviews along the way, such as Mauler's a measured response series. English subtitles are available. Thank you for watching! If you want to support my work, and get access to a substack-like blog in which I write about the Bible, the esoteric world, and analyze other fictional works, including movies, music clips and etc., you can check out my Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/thefirelinkconspiracy/membership I've made 3 articles available to free members. ;) Timestamps: 00:00 - 03:05 Intro 03:06 - 05:27 Dark Souls 2's reputation 05:28 - 21:48 The opening cinematic, difficulty for difficulty's sake 21:49 - 32:25 ''Multiple enemies'' 32:26 - 37:53 Boss design, animation tracking 37:54 - 42:22 Enemy placement, runbacks 42:23 - 58:33 Plot and characters 58:34 - 1:05:41 World design, Iron Keep's elevator 1:05:42 - 1:17:01 Level design and shortcuts 1:17:02 - 1:22:55 Non-linearity 1:22:56 - 1:27:13 Healing system 1:27:14 - 1:33:13 ADP, Agility, rolling, stamina 1:33:14 - 1:44:27 Covenants and misc. 1:44:28 - 1:53:37 Unfair mechanics, ambushes & hitboxes 1:53:38 - 1:57:09 Creature design & enemy variety 1:57:10 - 2:10:11 Soundtrack 2:10:12 - 2:21:32 Lore and ''fanservice''

You May Also Like

Enhance Your Gaming: Must-Have Essentials

AI-recommended products based on this video

Loading...
Dark Purple Braiding Hair Pre Stretched Yaki Straight 2 Packs 90g/Pack Extra Long Hair Extensions Crochet Braids 26 Inch/66 CM

Dark Purple Braiding Hair Pre Stretched Yaki Straight 2 Packs 90g/Pack Extra Long Hair Extensions Crochet Braids 26 Inch/66 CM

(9)
$23.39
FREE delivery Thu, Nov 6 on your first order
600+ bought in past month
Loading...
POUYRBA POUYRBA Graduation Cap Chocolate Decorations, 50pcs Black and Dark Blue 2026 Graduation Party Set for Chocolates Candies

POUYRBA POUYRBA Graduation Cap Chocolate Decorations, 50pcs Black and Dark Blue 2026 Graduation Party Set for Chocolates Candies

(162)
$32.98
FREE delivery Feb 17 - 19
Loading...
WWE 2K24 - PlayStation 4

WWE 2K24 - PlayStation 4

(616)
$31.86
Prime$5.29 delivery Mon, Jun 30Only 7 left in stock.
Loading...
EA SPORTS FC 25 - PlayStation 4

EA SPORTS FC 25 - PlayStation 4

(243)
$58.63$44.96
FREE delivery Tue, Jul 1
50+ bought in past month
Loading...
AC Power Cord Cable Fit for Sony PS5 PS4 PS3 Slim PlayStation 5 4 3, Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One X/S, TV, Printer Universal 2 Prong Supply Replacement - (ETL Listed Cable)

AC Power Cord Cable Fit for Sony PS5 PS4 PS3 Slim PlayStation 5 4 3, Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One X/S, TV, Printer Universal 2 Prong Supply Replacement - (ETL Listed Cable)

(5,351)
$8.49
Prime
500+ bought in past month
Loading...
SABRENT M.2 NVMe SSD 4TB Gen 4, Internal Solid State 7100MB/s Read, PCIe 4.0 M2 Hard Drive for Gamers, Compatible with PlayStation 5, PS5 Console, PCs, NUC Laptops and Desktops (SB-RKT4P-4TB)

SABRENT M.2 NVMe SSD 4TB Gen 4, Internal Solid State 7100MB/s Read, PCIe 4.0 M2 Hard Drive for Gamers, Compatible with PlayStation 5, PS5 Console, PCs, NUC Laptops and Desktops (SB-RKT4P-4TB)

(250)
$659.99$550.24
FREE delivery Tue, Jun 17
Loading...
8Bitdo Media Remote for Xbox One, Xbox Series X and Xbox Series S (Short Edition, Infrared Remote)

8Bitdo Media Remote for Xbox One, Xbox Series X and Xbox Series S (Short Edition, Infrared Remote)

(553)
$26.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
50+ bought in past month
Loading...
KontrolFreek FPS Freek Galaxy White Performance Thumbsticks for Xbox One and Xbox Series X Controller

KontrolFreek FPS Freek Galaxy White Performance Thumbsticks for Xbox One and Xbox Series X Controller

(9,959)
$22.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
100+ bought in past month
Loading...
8Bitdo Wireless USB Adapter 2 for Switch, Windows, Mac & Steam Deck - Compatible With Xbox Series X & S, Xbox One Bluetooth, Switch Pro and PS5 Controllers (Black)

8Bitdo Wireless USB Adapter 2 for Switch, Windows, Mac & Steam Deck - Compatible With Xbox Series X & S, Xbox One Bluetooth, Switch Pro and PS5 Controllers (Black)

(5,446)
$26.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
200+ bought in past month
Loading...
4 Pack Rechargeable Batteries for Xbox Series X|S Controller,Charger Dock with 4 x 3600mWh NiMH Battery for Xbox One/Xbox Series X|S,Xbox One S/X/Elite Wireless Controller

4 Pack Rechargeable Batteries for Xbox Series X|S Controller,Charger Dock with 4 x 3600mWh NiMH Battery for Xbox One/Xbox Series X|S,Xbox One S/X/Elite Wireless Controller

(80)
$72.42$71.15
FREE delivery Aug 27 - Sep 4
Loading...
8Bitdo Wireless USB Adapter 2 for Switch, Windows, Mac & Steam Deck - Compatible With Xbox Series X & S, Xbox One Bluetooth, Switch Pro and PS5 Controllers (Black)

8Bitdo Wireless USB Adapter 2 for Switch, Windows, Mac & Steam Deck - Compatible With Xbox Series X & S, Xbox One Bluetooth, Switch Pro and PS5 Controllers (Black)

(5,446)
$26.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
200+ bought in past month
Loading...
Turtle Beach Recon 50 Gaming Headset for Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, PS5, PS4, PlayStation, Mobile, & PC with 3.5mm – Removable Mic, 40mm Speakers – Red/Blue

Turtle Beach Recon 50 Gaming Headset for Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, PS5, PS4, PlayStation, Mobile, & PC with 3.5mm – Removable Mic, 40mm Speakers – Red/Blue

(1,785)
$19.99
FREE delivery Fri, Jan 2 on your first order
1K+ bought in past month
Loading...
Turtle Beach Stealth 600 Wireless Multiplatform Amplified Gaming Headset for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, PC, PS5, PS4, Nintendo Switch, & Mobile – Bluetooth, 80-Hr Battery, Noise-Cancelling Mic – Black
Best Seller

Turtle Beach Stealth 600 Wireless Multiplatform Amplified Gaming Headset for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, PC, PS5, PS4, Nintendo Switch, & Mobile – Bluetooth, 80-Hr Battery, Noise-Cancelling Mic – Black

(3,680)
$99.96
FREE delivery Tue, Oct 14
800+ bought in past month
Loading...
Razer DeathAdder Essential Gaming Mouse: 6400 DPI Optical Sensor - 5 Programmable Buttons - Mechanical Switches - Rubber Side Grips - Classic Black

Razer DeathAdder Essential Gaming Mouse: 6400 DPI Optical Sensor - 5 Programmable Buttons - Mechanical Switches - Rubber Side Grips - Classic Black

(15,297)
$24.99$23.24
FREE delivery Sat, Apr 11 on your first order
400+ bought in past month
Loading...
Logitech K250 Bluetooth Keyboard with Numpad, Easy Connectivity, Compact Wireless Keyboard Made with Recycled Plastic, Spill-Resistant, Comfortable Keys - Windows/MacOS - Graphite
Best Seller

Logitech K250 Bluetooth Keyboard with Numpad, Easy Connectivity, Compact Wireless Keyboard Made with Recycled Plastic, Spill-Resistant, Comfortable Keys - Windows/MacOS - Graphite

(49)
$19.99$18.59
FREE delivery Mon, Aug 18 on your first order
Loading...
Logitech K400 Plus Wireless Touch TV Keyboard With Easy Media Control and Built-in Touchpad, HTPC Keyboard for PC-connected TV, Windows, Android, Chrome OS, Laptop, Tablet - Black
Best Seller

Logitech K400 Plus Wireless Touch TV Keyboard With Easy Media Control and Built-in Touchpad, HTPC Keyboard for PC-connected TV, Windows, Android, Chrome OS, Laptop, Tablet - Black

(38,516)
$39.98$35.98
FREE delivery Thu, Sep 4
500+ bought in past month
Loading...
CORSAIR iCUE Link XD5 RGB Elite LCD Pump-Reservoir Unit - D5 PWM Pump - 480x480 IPS LCD Screen - 22 Addressable RGB LEDs - 440ml Nylon Reservoir - White

CORSAIR iCUE Link XD5 RGB Elite LCD Pump-Reservoir Unit - D5 PWM Pump - 480x480 IPS LCD Screen - 22 Addressable RGB LEDs - 440ml Nylon Reservoir - White

(17)
$379.99
FREE delivery Sun, Aug 24
Loading...
CORSAIR iCUE Link XC7 RGB Elite CPU Water Block - Transparent Flow Chamber - 24 RGB LEDs - Fits Intel® LGA 1700, AMD® AM5 and Older - White

CORSAIR iCUE Link XC7 RGB Elite CPU Water Block - Transparent Flow Chamber - 24 RGB LEDs - Fits Intel® LGA 1700, AMD® AM5 and Older - White

(56)
$149.99$125.33
FREE delivery Sun, Aug 24
Loading...
CORSAIR Hydro X Series iCUE Link XH405i Custom Cooling Kit – Hardline Water Cooling Loop – XC7 Elite CPU Water Block – XD5 Elite D5 Pump Res – XR5 360mm Radiator – 3X QX120 RGB Fans

CORSAIR Hydro X Series iCUE Link XH405i Custom Cooling Kit – Hardline Water Cooling Loop – XC7 Elite CPU Water Block – XD5 Elite D5 Pump Res – XR5 360mm Radiator – 3X QX120 RGB Fans

(235)
$879.99
FREE delivery Sun, Aug 24
Loading...
Seagate Game Drive 4TB External Hard Drive Portable HDD - Compatible With PS4 (STGD4000400) blue

Seagate Game Drive 4TB External Hard Drive Portable HDD - Compatible With PS4 (STGD4000400) blue

(11,894)
$222.28
Loading...
Seagate Portable 4TB External Hard Drive HDD – USB 3.0 for PC, Mac, Xbox, & PS4 - 1-Year Rescue Service (STGX4000400)
Amazon's Choice

Seagate Portable 4TB External Hard Drive HDD – USB 3.0 for PC, Mac, Xbox, & PS4 - 1-Year Rescue Service (STGX4000400)

(252,140)
$144.99$130.49
FREE delivery Tue, Jun 17
500+ bought in past month
Loading...
NEW SteelSeries Arctis Nova 3 Multi-Platform Gaming Headset - Signature Arctis Sound - ClearCast Gen 2 Mic - PC, PS5/PS4, Xbox Series X|S, Switch, Mobile

NEW SteelSeries Arctis Nova 3 Multi-Platform Gaming Headset - Signature Arctis Sound - ClearCast Gen 2 Mic - PC, PS5/PS4, Xbox Series X|S, Switch, Mobile

(9,500)
$99.98$67.37
PrimeFREE delivery Sat, Jun 14
100+ bought in past month
Loading...
New SteelSeries Arctis Nova Pro for Xbox Multi-System Gaming Headset - Premium Hi-Fi Drivers - Hi-Res Audio - 360° Spatial - GameDAC Gen 2 - Quad-DAC - ClearCast Gen 2 Mic - Xbox, PC, PS5/PS4, Switch

New SteelSeries Arctis Nova Pro for Xbox Multi-System Gaming Headset - Premium Hi-Fi Drivers - Hi-Res Audio - 360° Spatial - GameDAC Gen 2 - Quad-DAC - ClearCast Gen 2 Mic - Xbox, PC, PS5/PS4, Switch

(517)
$209.41$122.65
PrimeFREE delivery Sat, Jun 14