Graham's Hierarchy of Disagreement

Sprouts August 18, 2022
Video Thumbnail
Sprouts Logo

Sprouts

@sprouts

About

We create cartoons that explain complicated ideas in simple language. Join us as a Youtube member for special perks: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC-RKpEc4eE9PwJaupN91xYQ/join

Video Description

When you discuss a topic and everyone agrees, the conversation often dies out quickly. But when you disagree, you're putting yourself in opposition to what was said and the discussion continues. Paul Graham, a computer engineer, therefore proposed a “Hierarchy of Disagreement” in 2008. Learn at which level you are able to articulate your disagreement. Hopefully it’s not just name-calling or responding to tone. Go to Patreon and join our efforts to educate teachers and others on how to communicate better: https://www.patreon.com/sprouts DOWNLOAD video without ads and background music 🤫 https://sproutsschools.com/video-lessons/ SIGN UP to our mailing list and never miss a new video from us 🔔: http://eepurl.com/dNU4BQ SOURCES and teaching resources 🎓: https://sproutsschools.com/grahams-hierarchy-of-disagreement/ VISIT our website : https://www.sproutsschools.com CONTRIBUTE by upvoting your favorite topic or suggesting new ones : https://sprouts.featureupvote.com/ THANKS to our patrons This video was made with the support of our Patrons: Andrea Basilio Rava, Angela, ArkiTechy, Artur, Badrah, Brilliant Minds Learning, Cedric.Wang, David Markham, Delandric Webb, Denis Kraus, Digital INnov8ors, Dr. Matthias Müller-Mellin, Duane Bemister, Esther Chiang, Eva Marie Koblin, Floris Devreese, Frari63, Gatsby Dkdc, Ginger, ICH KANN DEUTSCH UND ES WAR EINFACH!, Isabelle, Jana Heinze, Jannes Kroon, Jeffrey Cassianna, Joanne Doyle, Johan Klassen, John Burghardt, Jonathan Schwarz, Jorge Luis Mejia Velazquez, Karen Lewis, Kenneth Natvig, Leonel, Liskaya, Marcel, Marco VanGuff, María, Marq Short, Mathis Nu, Matthias Ruck, Mezes.Macko, Mindozone, Mique XO, Muhammad Humayun, Nicki, Okan Elibol, Paul Hopkins, Peter Bishop, Petra, Raymond Fujioka, Robert Cook, scripz, Sebastian Huaytan Meder, Si, Stefan Gros, Stephen, Stephen Clark, Stuart Bishop, Susan Schuster, Tetiana Gerasymova, The Freudian Centre, Tristan Scifo, Victor Paweletz, Wolfgang Vullhorst, Yohanan Schwartzman, Yvonne Clapham and all the others.Thank you! To join them visit www.patreon.com/sprouts COLLABORATORS Script: Jonas Koblin Script Editor: Morgan Lizop Artist: Pascal Gaggelli Voice: Matt Abbott Coloring: Nalin Editing: Peera Lertsukittipongsa Production: Selina Bador Sound Design: Miguel Ojeda SOUNDTRACKS Nice Toy - Studio Le Bus Guilty Pleasures - Olive Musique DIG DEEPER with these top videos and articles: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=INdKgBPEI-8 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sophistical_Refutations SOURCES https://www.britannica.com/topic/critical-race-theory/Basic-tenets-of-critical-race-theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Graham_(programmer)#Graham's_Hierarchy_of_Disagreement http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html QUOTES: WHO SAID WHAT? “Abortion is legal because babies can’t vote” — Joseph Bonkowski “No woman can call herself free who does not control her own body” — Margaret Sanger “Race and skin color are socially constructed, not biologically natural.” — 1st tenet, Critical Race Theory “If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.” — George Orwell CLASSROOM EXERCISE Visit our website to find out about suggested classroom activities! CHAPTER 00:00 Opening quotes and statement 00:52 Introduction 01:19 Graham's hierarchy of disagreement 01:32 Level 1: Name-calling 01:48 Level 2: Ad hominem 02:14 Level 3: Responding to tone 02:41 Level 4: Contradiction 03:08 Level 5: Counterargument 03:41 Level 6: Refutation 04:13 Level 7: Refuting the central point 05:05 Benefit of knowing the form of argument 06:06 What do you think? 06:58 Patrons credits 07:07 Ending #disagreement #communication #sproutslearning #paulgraham #hierarchyofdisagreements

Essential Debate Accessories

AI-recommended products based on this video

Loading...
Logitech G203 Wired Gaming Mouse, 8,000 DPI, Rainbow Optical Effect LIGHTSYNC RGB, 6 Programmable Buttons, On-Board Memory, Screen Mapping, PC/Mac Computer and Laptop Compatible - Black
Best Seller

Logitech G203 Wired Gaming Mouse, 8,000 DPI, Rainbow Optical Effect LIGHTSYNC RGB, 6 Programmable Buttons, On-Board Memory, Screen Mapping, PC/Mac Computer and Laptop Compatible - Black

(17,871)
$27.98$22.38
FREE delivery Tue, Oct 14 on your first order
500+ bought in past month
Loading...
Logitech G305 Lightspeed Wireless Gaming Mouse, Hero 12K Sensor, 12,000 DPI, Lightweight, 6 Programmable Buttons, 250h Battery Life, On-Board Memory, PC/Mac - Black

Logitech G305 Lightspeed Wireless Gaming Mouse, Hero 12K Sensor, 12,000 DPI, Lightweight, 6 Programmable Buttons, 250h Battery Life, On-Board Memory, PC/Mac - Black

(35,879)
$49.99$44.99
FREE delivery Mon, Jan 26
1K+ bought in past month
Loading...
HOMIEE HOMIEE 15.6-Inch Laptop Backpack, High-Capacity Backpack for Men Women USB Charging Port Travel/Business/College Backpack, Blue

HOMIEE HOMIEE 15.6-Inch Laptop Backpack, High-Capacity Backpack for Men Women USB Charging Port Travel/Business/College Backpack, Blue

(1,409)
$37.99
PrimeFREE delivery Sat, Jun 14
Loading...
RAOYI 5Pack 64GB USB Flash Drive USB Stick USB 2.0 Memory Stick Slide Retractable Thumb Drive 64G USB Drive USB Key for Data Storage (Black Red Blue Green Purple)

RAOYI 5Pack 64GB USB Flash Drive USB Stick USB 2.0 Memory Stick Slide Retractable Thumb Drive 64G USB Drive USB Key for Data Storage (Black Red Blue Green Purple)

(4,402)
$26.09
Prime
1K+ bought in past month
Loading...
Asus ZenScreen 16” Portable USB Monitor (MB169CK) - Full HD, IPS, Dual USB-C, Eye Care, Flicker Free, Blue Light Filter, Anti-Glare Surface, 360° Kickstand, 3 yr Warranty

Asus ZenScreen 16” Portable USB Monitor (MB169CK) - Full HD, IPS, Dual USB-C, Eye Care, Flicker Free, Blue Light Filter, Anti-Glare Surface, 360° Kickstand, 3 yr Warranty

(111)
$129.99$100.27
FREE delivery Jan 9 - Feb 4
100+ bought in past month
Loading...
RAOYI 5pcs 32GB USB 3.0 Flash Drive Memory Stick Fold Storage Thumb Stick Pen Drive U Disk Swivel Design (5 Mixed Colors: Black Red Blue Green Purple)

RAOYI 5pcs 32GB USB 3.0 Flash Drive Memory Stick Fold Storage Thumb Stick Pen Drive U Disk Swivel Design (5 Mixed Colors: Black Red Blue Green Purple)

(1,667)
$31.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
Loading...
Carrying Case for Nintendo Switch, Soft Switch Case, Switch Screen Protector, Thumb Grips Caps, Switch Accessories Protective Case for Switch Console, Portable Travel Carry Cases for Switch, Green

Carrying Case for Nintendo Switch, Soft Switch Case, Switch Screen Protector, Thumb Grips Caps, Switch Accessories Protective Case for Switch Console, Portable Travel Carry Cases for Switch, Green

(8)
$38.99
PrimeFREE delivery Sun, Jun 15
Loading...
for Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge Case with Screen Protector, Samsung S25 Edge Phone case,Slim Fit Military Grade Heavy Duty Rugged Protective Bumper Cover for Galaxy s25 Edge 5G (Green, S25 Edge)

for Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge Case with Screen Protector, Samsung S25 Edge Phone case,Slim Fit Military Grade Heavy Duty Rugged Protective Bumper Cover for Galaxy s25 Edge 5G (Green, S25 Edge)

(0)
$9.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
Loading...
Asuwish Phone Case for Samsung Galaxy S25 Plus S25+ 5G Wallet Cover With Tempered Glass Screen Protector and Crossbody Wrist Strap Flip Zipper Card Holder Cell S25plus 25S + S 25 25+ Women Girls Green

Asuwish Phone Case for Samsung Galaxy S25 Plus S25+ 5G Wallet Cover With Tempered Glass Screen Protector and Crossbody Wrist Strap Flip Zipper Card Holder Cell S25plus 25S + S 25 25+ Women Girls Green

(0)
$21.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
Loading...
Dell Inspiron 7640 Laptop - 16.0-inch 16:10 2.5K (2560x1600) Display, Intel Core Ultra 7-155H Processor, 16GB DDR5 RAM, 1TB SSD, Windows 11 Home, Onsite Service & Migrate - Ice Blue EPEAT

Dell Inspiron 7640 Laptop - 16.0-inch 16:10 2.5K (2560x1600) Display, Intel Core Ultra 7-155H Processor, 16GB DDR5 RAM, 1TB SSD, Windows 11 Home, Onsite Service & Migrate - Ice Blue EPEAT

(395)
$1,719.89
FREE delivery Sun, Aug 24
Loading...
Perfect Ice Refrigerator Water Filter Compatible with Whirlpool EDR3RXD1,EDR3RXD1B,4396841,4396710,4396710P,4396710B, Kenm0re 9083,9030,46-9030(3 Pack Blue)

Perfect Ice Refrigerator Water Filter Compatible with Whirlpool EDR3RXD1,EDR3RXD1B,4396841,4396710,4396710P,4396710B, Kenm0re 9083,9030,46-9030(3 Pack Blue)

(760)
$31.59
FREE delivery Tue, Sep 23 on your first order
100+ bought in past month
Loading...
NEEWER Advanced 18 inch LED Ring Light for Phone, LCD Touch Screen, 2.4G Remote Lights Control, 3200-5600K, Tripod Light for iPhone Action Camera, for Studio Makeup TikTok YouTube Video Salon (Black)

NEEWER Advanced 18 inch LED Ring Light for Phone, LCD Touch Screen, 2.4G Remote Lights Control, 3200-5600K, Tripod Light for iPhone Action Camera, for Studio Makeup TikTok YouTube Video Salon (Black)

(2,807)
$181.49
FREE delivery Sun, Aug 10
Loading...
NEEWER a6700 L Plate Compatible with Sony Alpha 6700, Quick Switch Aluminum Extendable Side Plate & Anti Twist Baseplate Compatible with Arca Swiss QR System DJI RS 2 RSC 2 RS 3 Pro Gimbals, CA048

NEEWER a6700 L Plate Compatible with Sony Alpha 6700, Quick Switch Aluminum Extendable Side Plate & Anti Twist Baseplate Compatible with Arca Swiss QR System DJI RS 2 RSC 2 RS 3 Pro Gimbals, CA048

(24)
$25.99
FREE delivery Thu, Jun 19 on your first order
Loading...
Razer BlackShark V2 X Gaming Headset: 50mm Drivers - Cardioid Mic - Memory Foam Cushion - Lightweight- Comfortable, Noise Isolating Earcups - for PC, PS4, PS5, Switch - 3.5mm Audio Jack - Black ECOLOGO

Razer BlackShark V2 X Gaming Headset: 50mm Drivers - Cardioid Mic - Memory Foam Cushion - Lightweight- Comfortable, Noise Isolating Earcups - for PC, PS4, PS5, Switch - 3.5mm Audio Jack - Black ECOLOGO

(17,449)
$54.98$48.21
FREE delivery Mon, Jan 26
3K+ bought in past month
Loading...
12V/24V 100W Car Laptop Charger USB C for Lenovo Thinkpad MacBook HP Dell Acer Asus,Google,MSI, LG, Samsung,Huawei,Surface pro 9 8, Razer, Chromebook, ROG Ally, Steam Deck and All Type-C Devices

12V/24V 100W Car Laptop Charger USB C for Lenovo Thinkpad MacBook HP Dell Acer Asus,Google,MSI, LG, Samsung,Huawei,Surface pro 9 8, Razer, Chromebook, ROG Ally, Steam Deck and All Type-C Devices

(6)
$29.99
FREE delivery Tue, Jun 17 on your first order
50+ bought in past month
Loading...
Razer Universal Quick Charging Stand for Xbox Series X|S: Magnetic Secure Charging - Matches Forza Horizon 5 Limited Edition Xbox Wireless Controller - USB Powered - (Controller Sold Separately)

Razer Universal Quick Charging Stand for Xbox Series X|S: Magnetic Secure Charging - Matches Forza Horizon 5 Limited Edition Xbox Wireless Controller - USB Powered - (Controller Sold Separately)

(1,103)
$52.27$33.70
PrimeFREE delivery Sat, Jun 14
Loading...
Replace Remote Compatible with Nakamichi Soundbar Shockwafe Elite 7.2.4 SSE,Shockwafe Elite 7.2 SSE 800W, Shockwafe Ultra 9.2 SSE, Shockwafe Ultra 9.2.4 Channel 1000W Dolby Atmos/DTS:X Sound Bar

Replace Remote Compatible with Nakamichi Soundbar Shockwafe Elite 7.2.4 SSE,Shockwafe Elite 7.2 SSE 800W, Shockwafe Ultra 9.2 SSE, Shockwafe Ultra 9.2.4 Channel 1000W Dolby Atmos/DTS:X Sound Bar

(1)
$84.65
FREE delivery Aug 25 - 27