Taylor Swift’s ‘Showgirl’ Is ACTUALLY Good. But Is It Romantic?

Popcast October 3, 2025
Video Thumbnail

About

No channel description available.

Video Description

“The Life of a Showgirl,” Taylor Swift’s 12th original studio album, is out now and finds the superstar taking stock of her relationship with fiancé Travis Kelce, while also tending to some unfinished business with unnamed enemies. Jon Caramanica, a critic at The Times, and Joe Coscarelli, a culture reporter — both longtime Swiftologists — sat down to dissect the 12 new songs, including who they might be about and why Swift’s music lends itself such detective work in the first place. Check out the guys’ personal rankings of Taylor’s best albums here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6t7C_NIkDPk 0:14 Intro 2:28 Max Martin and Shellback 9:28 Initial takeaways 15:08 “The Fate of Ophelia”/”Elizabeth Taylor” 24:06 “Opalite” 28:58 “Father Figure” 32:59 “Eldest Daughter” 40:10 “Actually Romantic,” Charli XCX & Olivia Rodrigo 48:49 Giggling over “Wood” 54:34 Snack Time! + “Cancelled”/“Honey”/”The Life of a Showgirl” Follow Jon: https://twitter.com/joncaramanica https://www.instagram.com/joncaramanica Follow Joe: https://twitter.com/joecoscarelli https://www.instagram.com/joecoscarelli/ Listen to every Popcast ever https://www.nytimes.com/popcast Every episode of Popcast (Deluxe) on YouTube https://tinyurl.com/PopcastDeluxe Popcast Discord! https://tinyurl.com/PopcastDiscord Popcast Facebook! https://tinyurl.com/PopcastFacebook Popcast t-shirts & stickers http://itsthepopcast.myshopify.com Subscribe: http://bit.ly/U8Ys7n More from The New York Times Video: http://nytimes.com/video

Capture Your Own Showstopper Moments

AI-recommended products based on this video

Loading...
SmallRig Z 8 L-Bracket for Nikon Z8 Z 8 Camera, Quick Release L Plate for Arca-Type for Nikon Z 8, Quick Switch Between Horizontal and Vertical Shooting, for Landscape, Animal Photography - 3942

SmallRig Z 8 L-Bracket for Nikon Z8 Z 8 Camera, Quick Release L Plate for Arca-Type for Nikon Z 8, Quick Switch Between Horizontal and Vertical Shooting, for Landscape, Animal Photography - 3942

(35)
$61.97
FREE delivery Thu, Jun 19
Loading...
NEEWER Zf Handgrip L Shape Grip for Nikon Z f, Ultra Thin Retro Formfitting Camera Mounting Baseplate with Handle & Aluminum Shutter Button Cap, Compatible with Arca Swiss Tripod Fluid Head, CA073

NEEWER Zf Handgrip L Shape Grip for Nikon Z f, Ultra Thin Retro Formfitting Camera Mounting Baseplate with Handle & Aluminum Shutter Button Cap, Compatible with Arca Swiss Tripod Fluid Head, CA073

(236)
$33.99
FREE delivery Thu, Jun 19 on your first order
Loading...
NEEWER CA076 Zfc Handgrip L Shape Grip for Nikon Z fc, Ultra Thin Retro Formfitting Camera Mounting Baseplate with Handle/Brass Shutter Button, Compatible with Arca Swiss Tripod Fluid Head, Black

NEEWER CA076 Zfc Handgrip L Shape Grip for Nikon Z fc, Ultra Thin Retro Formfitting Camera Mounting Baseplate with Handle/Brass Shutter Button, Compatible with Arca Swiss Tripod Fluid Head, Black

(175)
$33.99
FREE delivery Thu, Jun 19 on your first order
Loading...
NEEWER Advanced 18 inch LED Ring Light for Phone, LCD Touch Screen, 2.4G Remote Lights Control, 3200-5600K, Tripod Light for iPhone Action Camera, for Studio Makeup TikTok YouTube Video Salon (Black)

NEEWER Advanced 18 inch LED Ring Light for Phone, LCD Touch Screen, 2.4G Remote Lights Control, 3200-5600K, Tripod Light for iPhone Action Camera, for Studio Makeup TikTok YouTube Video Salon (Black)

(2,807)
$181.49
FREE delivery Sun, Aug 10
Loading...
NEEWER Advanced 18 inch LED Ring Light for Phone, LCD Touch Screen, 2.4G Remote Lights Control, 3200-5600K, Tripod Light for iPhone Action Camera, for Studio Makeup TikTok YouTube Video Salon (Black)

NEEWER Advanced 18 inch LED Ring Light for Phone, LCD Touch Screen, 2.4G Remote Lights Control, 3200-5600K, Tripod Light for iPhone Action Camera, for Studio Makeup TikTok YouTube Video Salon (Black)

(2,807)
$181.49
FREE delivery Sun, Aug 10
Loading...
SanDisk 128GB Extreme PRO SDXC UHS-I Memory Card - C10, U3, V30, 4K UHD, SD Card - SDSDXXD-128G-GN4IN
Best Seller

SanDisk 128GB Extreme PRO SDXC UHS-I Memory Card - C10, U3, V30, 4K UHD, SD Card - SDSDXXD-128G-GN4IN

(71,074)
$29.99$26.61
FREE delivery Sun, Aug 10 on your first order
4K+ bought in past month
Loading...
Kaiess 62" Tripod for iPhone, Selfie Stick Tripod & Phone Tripod Stand with Remote, Cell Phone Tripod for iPhone, Extendable Travel Tripod Compatible with iPhone 14/13/12 Pro Max/Android
Best Seller

Kaiess 62" Tripod for iPhone, Selfie Stick Tripod & Phone Tripod Stand with Remote, Cell Phone Tripod for iPhone, Extendable Travel Tripod Compatible with iPhone 14/13/12 Pro Max/Android

(5,298)
$28.98
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
1K+ bought in past month
Loading...
SmallRig ZV-E1 Camera Baseplate for Sony ZV-E1, Built-in Cold Shoe Mount and QR Plate (for Arca) Quick Switch Between Tripod and Stabilizer for DJI RS 2 / RSC 2 / RS 3 / RS 3 Pro - 4314

SmallRig ZV-E1 Camera Baseplate for Sony ZV-E1, Built-in Cold Shoe Mount and QR Plate (for Arca) Quick Switch Between Tripod and Stabilizer for DJI RS 2 / RSC 2 / RS 3 / RS 3 Pro - 4314

(3)
$44.99
FREE delivery Thu, Jun 19
Loading...
SmallRig Baseplate for Sony Alpha 6700, Bottom Mount Plate Built-in Quick Release Plate for Arca, Supporting Quick Switch Between Tripod and Stabilizer (for DJI RS 2 / RSC 2 / RS 3 / RS 3 Pro) - 4338

SmallRig Baseplate for Sony Alpha 6700, Bottom Mount Plate Built-in Quick Release Plate for Arca, Supporting Quick Switch Between Tripod and Stabilizer (for DJI RS 2 / RSC 2 / RS 3 / RS 3 Pro) - 4338

(85)
$38.24
FREE delivery Thu, Jun 19
Loading...
JOREST 38Pcs Small Precision Screwdriver Set, Tool Gifts for Men, Christmas Gifts for him with Torx T5, T6, Repair Tool Kit for MacBook, Computer, Laptop, iPhone, PS4 PS5, Xbox, Switch, Glasses

JOREST 38Pcs Small Precision Screwdriver Set, Tool Gifts for Men, Christmas Gifts for him with Torx T5, T6, Repair Tool Kit for MacBook, Computer, Laptop, iPhone, PS4 PS5, Xbox, Switch, Glasses

(43,599)
$14.07
FREE delivery Thu, Nov 27 on your first order
1K+ bought in past month
Loading...
AKASO V50 Elite 4K60fps Touch Screen WiFi Action Camera Voice Control EIS 131 feet Waterproof Camera 8X Zoom Remote Control with with 64GB U3 MicroSDXC Memory Card Global Recycled Standard

AKASO V50 Elite 4K60fps Touch Screen WiFi Action Camera Voice Control EIS 131 feet Waterproof Camera 8X Zoom Remote Control with with 64GB U3 MicroSDXC Memory Card Global Recycled Standard

(848)
$219.99
FREE delivery Sun, Aug 24
Loading...
Selfie Stick, 7 Section Adjustable Action Camera Extension Pole with 1/4in Thread and Screw Hole, 23.5 to 120cm Portable Extension Rod for Panoramic Camera

Selfie Stick, 7 Section Adjustable Action Camera Extension Pole with 1/4in Thread and Screw Hole, 23.5 to 120cm Portable Extension Rod for Panoramic Camera

(0)
$14.49
FREE delivery Aug 27 - Sep 17
Loading...
NEEWER Advanced 18 inch LED Ring Light for Phone, LCD Touch Screen, 2.4G Remote Lights Control, 3200-5600K, Tripod Light for iPhone Action Camera, for Studio Makeup TikTok YouTube Video Salon (Black)

NEEWER Advanced 18 inch LED Ring Light for Phone, LCD Touch Screen, 2.4G Remote Lights Control, 3200-5600K, Tripod Light for iPhone Action Camera, for Studio Makeup TikTok YouTube Video Salon (Black)

(2,807)
$181.49
FREE delivery Sun, Aug 10
Loading...
DJI Osmo Action 4 Standard Combo, 4K/120fps Waterproof Action Camera with a 1/1.3-Inch Sensor, Stunning Low-Light Imaging,10-bit & D-Log M Color Performance, Long-Lasting 160 Mins, Outdoor Camera

DJI Osmo Action 4 Standard Combo, 4K/120fps Waterproof Action Camera with a 1/1.3-Inch Sensor, Stunning Low-Light Imaging,10-bit & D-Log M Color Performance, Long-Lasting 160 Mins, Outdoor Camera

(3,962)
299.00
PrimeFREE delivery Saturday, June 14
500+ bought in past month